Welcome
Introduction

Various types

Updates

Reports

Distribution

Illustrations

Contact us

Observations and conclusion



Distribution and use

  • The classic type A tiger bells have the widest distribution area. They occur in many countries in Northwest, Southwest and Southeast Asia and in Europe (Russia, Malta).
  • Although the tiger bells are clearly of Chinese origin, few tiger bells are reported in mainland China. However in the north east and in the south these bells are found with ethnic minorities practicing animism and shamanism.
  • In most regions in Asia and with most ethnic groups, the type A tiger bells are related to shamanism and magic. In regions of Afghanistan and Pakistan with a shamanic pre-islamic past these tiger bells were used as dance bells and to protect animals.
  • With those groups that use the type A tiger bells for animals, these animals often have a special religious (dogs in Tibet) or supernatural (cats with the Minangkabau) status. With the Akha (Chang Mai region) and in one case in Burma, type A tiger bells seem to have been used for animals without any supernatural connotation.
  • Large numbers of type A tiger bells are found in Southeast Siberia, Northeast China and Mongolia where they were, and are, used by shamans. These bells are commonly found with certain ethnic groups in insular Southeast Asia, such as in Borneo (Sarawak and Kalimantan) where they are used by Dayak belian (local shamans). The Iban and Bidayu Dayak from Sarawak have large numbers of tiger bells and use these bells as amulets. In the southern Philippines (Mindanao, Mindoro) tiger bells are used as amulets and dance bells. The Iban Dayak have the largest variation in size of type A tiger bells, with diameters up to 5 c.m.
  • New tiger bells are found in Singapore, in China, Mongolia and South Siberia. New variations of the type A tiger bells are sold in Chinese shops in the Western world. These new bells are mass produced in China.
  • In Turkey, in a bazaar in Istanbul, three classic type A tiger bells were found. It has not yet been ascertained that they are connected to one or more ethnic groups in Turkey.
  • In Malta several dozens of tiger bells are in still in use by horse owners. Most likely the bells arrived in Malta during the period that Malta was part of the British Empire, together with other countries such as Hong Kong.
  • For several years new tiger bells based on type A bells have been found in large numbers, as shaman attributes, as amulets, and in internet shops. These bells are mass produced in factories in China, and possibly on a smaller scale in South Korea and in Taiwan.

Type B
Tiger bells type B have a smaller distribution area, restricted to the East Asian continent. They do not occur in insular S.E. Asia, and are rare in the Chinese and Siberian north east. However on the East Asian mainland the bells are very common and mostly used as animal bells, for yaks, horses and cows. In Nepal, Tibet and, occasionally, in Northeast China, B type tiger bells are used by shamans. In Thailand these bells are for sale in large numbers in handicraft shops but it was not clear what they were used for.Sometimes they are used as door knobs in Chinese type houses.

Type C
Tiger bells type C are found in Nepal, where they are very common, in Bhutan and possibly in Tibet. These bells, tied to belts and chains are used by shamans, and for animals. The bells are reported to be produced in India (Dehra dun, Rajpur).

Type D
Until now, tiger bells type D have been found in small numbers in Vietnam, Burma and probably Laos. They are used as horse bells (Vietnam, Laos) and as a musical instrument (Burma).

Alternatives
In several places variations of the type A bell and B bells are found. Alternative type A bells from Nepal, Syria and China and alternative type B bells from Bangladesh are examples. Some variations occur in large numbers. Many of these bells are newly made bells.

No tiger bells present
No tiger bells are reported in Japan, Sikkim, Sri Lanka, Islamic South-West and West Asia, except Turkey, and the Arab part of the Middle East.

Focus on tiger bells type A
The distribution patterns and the information available on the types B, C, D and the Alternatives are either too general (type B) or too limited (type C and D) to come to any conclusions on their age and history.The Alternatives have too many differences in design and distribution. The tiger bells of type A are however distributed in distinct patterns and over identifiable groups. These bells are highly valued and sometimes even revered by their owners who went to great length to find a constant supply of tiger bells.This and their enormous distribution area, make these bells better subjects to try to follow them through time over the Asian continent. Therefore I will concentrate on the classic type A tiger bell only.


Age of tiger bells

On the age of the tiger bells information varies. The estimates given here are from new to old:

  • New tiger bells are being produced in East China, Peking, and possibly in Mongolia and Taiwan.
  • In 1976 one Tagakaolu tribesman (from Mindanao, the Philippines) said that the tiger bells in posession of the group were 'older than fifty years'. This estimate gave more an impression of a very long time than an accurate estimate.
  • In Malta several tens of tiger bells were bought by local horse owners. They claim that these bells are more than one hundred years old (reported in 2011).
  • One antique dealer in Nanking sold one tiger bell of a rough A type and said that the bell was from the Kuang Hsu dynasty which ruled from 1875 - 1908. The bell would be about 100 to 150 years old.
  • A horse bell of which the design is a variation close to the classic tiger bells, is said to originate from the Manchu Qing dynasty (AD 1644 - 1911).
  • A tiger bell offered on eBay is from the Middle East (no country or region is given) and is presented as being from the 15th to the 16th century.
  • On eBay one bell from Afghanistan is presented as dating from 1700 - 1800 AD. The same company offers a bell from Pakistan dating from 1600 - 1700 AD. Thus the age of the bells would be about 300 to 400 years old. However the link of the arrival of these bells with the Mongolian armies and their Hazara and Turkic soldiers could bring the age back to the 15th and even the13th century.
  • The two tiger bells from Russia that were found in a potato field near Tver (150 km. north-west of Moscow) can also be dated as from the Mongol invasions in the 13th to 15th century.
  • One antique dealer in Singapore, Tiepolo's mr. David Mun, said that the bells were not older that 600 to 700 years and probably from the Han dynasty.
  • Ethnographics, curio and antique dealer Eddy Lauren in Legian, Bali, stated that a small tiger bell from Timor was from 'before Majapahit', about 1300 AD, so older than 700 years.
  • Antropologist and Tungus-expert, the late Mr. S. Shirokogorov dated the emergence of Siberian shamanism during the 11th century. That included the development of ceremonies, the role and presence of the drum and the costume, with its metal attributes such as bronze mirrors (toli). Most likely from the very beginning the tiger bells were also part of this outfit . That would mean that the oldest tiger bells could very well be dated at the same period: appr. 900 years ago.
  • Tom Ulbrich and Bui Kim Dinh from Vietnam reported a tiger bell from Northern Vietnam. The bell's age was estimated at about 1000 years by an antique dealer and expert.
  • One antique dealer in Klaten (mr. Om Bram, East Java) had a small A type tiger bell. According to him the bell was from the T'ang dynasty, about 500 AD. That would set the bells' age at about 1500 years.

Mr. Shirokogorov's estimate, about 900 years ago, seems to fit best with the rest of the events that caused the remarkable distribution of tiger bells.


Production
  • There are many variations in the design and the quality of the classic tiger bells. They were produced with the 'lost wax' process, probably using clay molds and clay stamps. Because of the wide distribution area and the sometimes large concentrations found , type A tiger bells must have been produced on a large scale, probably many thousands, over hundreds of years. This would explain the many variations: even using molds or stamps, the lost wax process could not guarantee identical products: molds wear out, stamps are made again and again from copies made of copies. However the basic motif has remained remarkably unchanged.
  • Tiger bells larger than about 2,5 c.m. have different sides, notable in the characters and minor differences in the design. The smaller bells have identical sides.
  • Tiger bells were produced in batches. Through time, different molds were used: tiger bells from Afghanistan, Pakistan and East Kalimantan are almost identical; some Iban bells and the bell from the Bahau Dayak are identical to the Kaudern bell from Sulawesi.
  • Some bells look new, others are roughly finished. With some bells the motif has changed, the lines are of poor quality, hoops are rough, not centered or round instead of rectangular. These things indicate mass-production with at times less strict quality control. Production continued over centuries, probably until the beginning of the 20th century when shamanism was banned by the Rusian and Chinese communists. Because of the large numbers produced it is possible that there were different production facilities. The location of these production facilities, and probably also the origin of the tiger bells, is almost certainly in Northeast China (Manchuria). There is one indication of supporting production facilities in another part of Asia (in Taiwan) but most likely the majority came from the China-Manchuria region, maybe even from one foundry in that region. It is possible that alternative bells (type A tiger bells with variations in the design) were produced in other places in Asia.
  • In an article on the social status of users of different types of tiger bells among the Puyuma of Taiwan author Lancini Jen-Hao Cheng suggests that tiger bells have been and still are produced in Taiwan.
  • New variations of the tiger bells are made in a workshop in Peking.
  • A newly made alternative bell from Syria, for sale in hardware stores, is said to be produced locally. However the bell is identical to an alternative bell from Korea, also newly made.
  • Since the year 2000 an industrial factory in east China produces tiger bells in large quantities. These bells are offered on internet websites all over the world, where they are often presented as old or antique bells. The new bells from southern Mongolia, several bells from Korea, several examples based on the design from the Qing dynasty and other alternative bells were most likely produced in this factory.

Other observations

Proto Malayans
In the Philippines, Indonesia and Malaysia (Sarawak), ethnic groups that have these bells are all descendants from a group sometimes called the Proto Malayans, in other sources they are referred to as the Ancient Peoples. However not all Ancient People have tiger bells.

Tiger bells in insular S.E.Asia

In the Philippines, no tiger bells have been reported in North Luzon. We do find tiger bells in Mindoro, with the Mangyan, and in Palawan, the Tagbanwa. In South East Mindanao many tiger bells are found with several groups: Tagakaolu, Bagobo, B'laan, Mandaya, Manuvu. Other, sometimes neighbouring groups in the region (T'boli, neighbouring B'laan, Tiruray) do not have tiger bells. The groups that have tiger bvells also practice a different kind of gong chime playing technique: the gongs are suspended on a vertical frame. Groups without tiger bells such as most of the muslim groups and the T'boli, play the gong chime on a horizontal frame.

In the moslim region (West Mindanao and the Sulu Archipel), several tiger bells have been reported with the Maranaw and there is a report of tiger bells used as money 'in the Moro south'. The name 'Moro south' is sometimes used as a generic term for the non-Christian areas in Mindanao.

In Sarawak (Malaysian Borneo), tiger bells are common and used in large numbers with the Iban and the Bidayu Dayak. No tiger bells were reported with the Kelabit Dayak and the Melanau Dayak.

In Kalimantan (Indonesia Borneo) tiger bells are common and used in large numbers with groups such as the Kenyah, Kayan and Benuaq Dayak. The Ngadju are one large Dayak group without tiger bells.

Origin of the Iban of Sarawak
The Iban arrived in Borneo in around 1675. They came from Sumatra, Indonesia. DNA research has shown that their ancestors lived on the S.E. Asian mainland, possibly in what is now northern Thailand, an area that is home to a number of ethnic groups that until today practise shamanism and used (and possibly still use) tiger bells (Karen, Akha, Hmong). It is possible that the Ibans' ancestors brought their tiger bells from the S.E. Asian mainland, first to their location on Sumatra, then to Borneo. Possibly the growing influence of Islam in Sumatra has forced the Iban's ancestors to leave the island.

Neo-Siberians and Paleo-Siberians
In Eastern Siberia classic tiger bells occur in large numbers on the shaman costumes of ethnic groups belonging to the Neo-Siberians, e.g. the Ewenk. With these groups the shaman's costume is much more elaborately decorated than with groups belonging to the Paleo-Siberians.The Paleo-Siberian Gilyak are an exception: their shamanic practices and attributes were strongly influenced by the Neo-Siberian Ewenk.
Very few reports of tiger bells in mainland China
Although all tiger bells evidently demonstrate a Chinese origin, reports of tiger bells in China are scarce. The examples that I know off concern tiger bells used as an amulet, in local or regional folklore and among ethnic minorities, particularly in the south (Yunnan).

Large numbers of tiger bells however occur in the northern parts of today's China: Manchuria and Inner Mongolia, where for centuries shamanism was the main religion.

The fact that tiger bells do not occur among the Han Chinese (China's main ethnic group) is probably because they were Buddhist, China's main religion since appr. 200 B.C.
Shamanism and bronze objects, in S.E. Siberia, N.E. China and Mongolia
The classic form of Siberian shamanism used to be practised by ethnic groups in S.E. Siberia (Ewenk, Nanaj, Gilyak, etc.), N.E. China (Manchuria and Inner Mongolia: Solon, Manjagir), Mongolia and Tuva, etc. This form of shamanism is best known from pictures and recordings of séances by the shamans of the Ewenk and related groups. Characteristic are the drum and a special costume decorated with many metal objects such as bronze mirrors, many bronze tiger bells and bells of other types (clapper bells, conical bells). This form of shamanism found its definite form in the 11th century (according to Tungus-expert S. Shirokogorov) and most likely included all bronze and other metal objects. This means that tiger bells could very well be from before the 11th century. Craftmanship to produce these objects was since long present: bronze mirrors were already known long before the 11th century and the bronze casters of the Shang and Chou dynasties (1600 - 250 BC) were capable of casting bronzes of incredible complexity.

Decline and revival of shamanism in the former Soviet Union and China
At the beginning of the 20th century shamanism was banned by the communist regimes of the Soviet Union and China. Shamans were arrested, costumes and attributes destroyed. During that period several valuable costumes were given away or sold by shamans to explorers, such as H. Haslund Kristensen, to save them from destruction. The same happened in communist China. In the early 20th century shamanism was considered to be completely abolished. This also ended the production of the attributes, including the tiger bells. All classic tiger bells are older than 100 years. After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 a revival of shamanism began in several East Siberian states (e.g. Tuva). These new shamans or shamans that survived the ban need the traditional paraphernalia. Most of these however had been destroyed by local old regime leaders. Now these objects are being produced again and so are tiger bells. These new bells have variations in design but are clearly based on the tiger's head motif. In China shamanism is still discouraged and considered to be dead, although re-enactments of séances are presented for tourists in regional museums.
Europe
In Europe, tiger bells were found in Turkey, Malta and Russia. The presence in Turkey could possibly be related to the shamanic past of Turkish ethnic groups.

The presence in Malta is almost certainly a result of trade activities combined with a passion for horses during the period when Malta was part of the British Empire, together with a.o. Hong Kong.

The bells from Tver, found by Dmitri Timoshenko in a potato field, are very old. He suggests that the bells were brought along during Mongol invasions in the 13th century.
The Mongol invasions, the Hazara and the Turkish armies

A map, found in Wikipedia, shows a remarkable similarity between the span of the Mongol Empire and the distribution area of the tiger bells. The religion of the Mongols was a mixture of Buddhist and shamanic elements. They influenced and were influenced by shamanism of the Tungus (Ewenk). Given the time in which these invasions took place (two centuries after the emergence of Siberian shamanism) it is obvious that the Mongol invasions played a major role in the spread of elements of Siberian shamanism, and with that the tiger bells, over the Asian continent.

This is confirmed by Dutch anthropologist Hendrik Wittenberg who reacted on the report of mr.Timoshenko's find. He writes the following:

In my opinion the Mongols were the most important actors in the spread of the tiger bell which they had given an iconic meaning. Many rulers of the Khan family positioned themselves as shamans. And how far did they get! There even were raids to Indonesia and fights against Javanese royals...

Shamanism in Afghanistan and Pakistan
In a paper titled Malang, Sufis, and Mystics, dr. Muhammad Humayun Sidky describes the arrival of shamanism from North Asia into Afghanistan and Pakistan before Islam became the dominant religion.

In Central Asia, shamanism was once prevalent among the Turkic peoples, originally occupying the area of the Altai mountains. By the sixth century the Turks had invaded the Central Asian steppes, bringing with them their shamanistic beliefs along with cults of ancestors, stones, mountains, and the earth goddess Otukan...

Despite the Muslim hegemony which was established over a large section of Central Asia after the seventh century, many shamanic practices survived.

From the 13th to the 15th century the Mongols invaded many parts of Asia. Just as the Mongols, the inhabitants of Central and Northern Asia were animists and shamanists, among them the Hazara and Turkic people. They joined the Mongol armies. When the Mongols invaded Afghanistan and Pakistan, they met the descendents of the Turkic invaders from the 6th century. These descendents were now islamized but still practiced many shamanic rituals. The tiger bells, brought there by Mongol shamanism, were easily adopted. The Hazara stayed, some of the Turkic people travelled on. When Islam became more and more strict the tiger bells degraded from shaman attributes to dance bells, amulets and animal bells. Nowadays forms of shamanism are still practiced in Afghanistan.
New bells
From North America there is one report of a basket full of newly made tiger bells (similar to the Qing bell, a bell from Burma and a bell from Korea) in a Chinese shop in New York. Because of the large number of bells they were probably for local use, e.g. as an amulet (as in Singapore). The same happened in the Netherlands (Amsterdam). Since the year 2000 a new factory in East China mass produces various tiger bells. These bells are mostly sold via Internet.

Is the tiger bell a migration tracer?


Summarizing:

Tiger bells (distinguishable from other jingle bells by the design: a tiger's face) are an important part of the shaman dress used in Siberian shamanism. They also occur as amulets and dance attributes in several parts of the Asian continent and in ISEA (Insular South East Asia).

Since the beginning of Siberian shamanism in the 11th century tiger bells, together with other metal and bronze objects, were an indispensable part of the shaman's costume, particularly among the Neo-Siberians, mainly Ewenk and sub-groups. Siberian shamanism was and is concentrated in the area East Mongolia, Inner Mongolia, S.E. Siberia and N. E. China (Manchuria).

Tiger bells were produced in large numbers in N.E. China, for hundreds of years: from the 11th century, possibly earlier, until the end of the 19th century.

Although many of these bells remained within the area, large numbers were transported to, and probably by ethnic groups who practiced shaman rituals; particularly in Taiwan, South China, continental S.E. Asia (Thailand, Vietnam, Burma, etc.) and ISEA. This process took place during two migrations: one from Northern China's mainland to Taiwan, and one crossing China's mainland via Yunnan, Thailand, Laos, Vietnam to Malaysia, Indonesia and the Southern Philippines. The time these migrations took place coincides with the emergence of shamanism in N.E. Asia and, relatively shortly after that, the Mongol invasions, from the 13th to 15th century. The invasions could very well have been one cause for these migrations,

The third migration responsible for the spread of the tiger bell was directly caused by the Mongol invasions. The Mongol armies were accompanied by shamans, and by soldiers of Turkic and Mongolian descent. They arrived in the Afghanistan-Pakistan area where the Mongol soldiers were assimilated by local islamised but still shamanism practising ethnic groups, thus forming the Hazara. Some Turkic people stayed, others went on further to the west. The Mongolian shamans brought the tiger bells into the Afghan-Pakistan area and, even further, into Eastern Europe.These three migrations are clearly indicated by the presence of the tiger bells. After the initial introduction by the shamans tradesmen could very well have taken care of further supplies of tiger bells, produced in Northern China.

Production of the tiger bells stopped at the beginning of the 20th century, when shamanism was banned by the Soviet and Chinese governments.

After the decline of the communist system in the Soviet Union, shamanism revived in some East Asian countries (such as Tuva). Costumes and attributes are made again and so are the tiger bells. Since 2000 tiger bells are produced in large numbers and variations, in at least one large scale factory in East China. These new bells are sold all over the world, in local shops and through the internet. Most of these new tiger bells are easily distinguished from the tiger bells from before the 20th century.


Concluding: the three main streams of migrations mentioned above brought the tiger bells to where they are now. Their presence indicates how far the influence of the Mongol invasions is noticeable. For these three migrations the tiger bells can be seen as migration tracers . Of course there were other factors as well that decided where the tiger bells would find a place. Trade is one such factor, gifts and barter are other factors. However the overall pattern and the continuing demand for tiger bells by certain groups were almost certainly decided by the influence of the shamans of fhe Mongolians.

The very first idea, a common origin for all ethnic groups that had or have tiger bells, had to be abandoned in an early stage. When it comes to migration waves and movements of populations over continents, the reality is far more complex.


Go back, to the top of the page
or continue to the next page

All text and photographs are copyrighted,
for information please contact F. de Jager